Viudas (2011) Reviews

• I enjoyed it.

  myotherpetisdog2018-08-22

  Graciela Borges was 70 when this movie was made. What a beauty! I find Argentinian women strikingly beautiful. I enjoyed watching this movie, but it won't appeal to the Hollywood audience.

• A simple story told through a brilliant acting.

  faezdel2013-07-16

  The story is quite simple. Augusto suffers a heart attack and he's brought to the hospital by Adela, his young mistress. Elena, Augusto's wife, goes there too. That's where the two women meet. They've been sharing a man during 5 years; Elena never noticed it. They're so different but, at the same time, so alike: both of them are alone and almost desperate after the sudden departure of their man. And they try to support each other, the best they can do. Elena as sort of a stepmother to Adela; Adela as the daughter that Elena never had. They have to learn about each other. It will take time, and many scars have to heal through the whole process. Some questions have no answer during the whole movie. What's Adela's background? Is she alone in the world? Where are her parents? Are they alive or not? Why is she so much obsessed with Elena? Why does she need to be accepted by her? I'd like the movie to go deeper into these matters. That's probably the biggest flaw in the plot. Graciela Borges as Elena is flawless, as usual. She's so full of herself, and cannot believe she has been cheated for such a long time (she had portrayed a very similar character a year earlier, the bossy Susana in "Dos hermanos"). Esther, her best friend and unconditional accomplice, is brilliantly played by Rita Cortese. The friendship between these two mature women is one of the strongest points of the film. Valeria Bertuccelli as the young, immature and disoriented Adela gives a quite credible performance too. I also need to mention Justina, the androgynous maid, who is constantly challenging her boss. She doesn't care, Elena cannot fire her: she knows "too much". She adds the bizarre and comic bits, they are a breath of fresh air in the middle of so much tension between the two principal characters. I'd say there's not much story: just two women who have to accept each other's existence. But the whole movie is saved by the amazing acting. That's Borges, Cortese and Martin Bossi as Justina. I really enjoyed the movie, and I think a sequel would be necessary to tell us more about their past. And about their future, too. My rate: 7/10.

• I thought the younger woman was not the lover

  tomokoi2017-09-06

  It was a strange movie. I could not believe the story at the end. I was hoping there must be a twist and the younger woman was not the lover. However, Adela had been having an affair with the husband and Adela had her baby at the end. It is a horrible story. I do not think there is anything educational about this part. Black humor? It was not really funny. The gay maid was funny. Is this comedy? If I try to understand, the wife is old. Once her husband dies, the wife will be alone. So it may be better for her to have a daughter like Adela. Adela have a baby, so the wife can have a grandchild, so the wife will never be alone. But still it is a strange story.

• Mesmerizing

  davidtraversa-969472016-03-07

  Enjoyable from beginning to end. The technical side of this film is so good that you forget there is a camera between you and the actors. Photography, lighting, sound: Sheer perfection. Not to mention the acting: These actors could have been directed by Ingmar Bergman. Marcos Carnevale was the director, as good as the Swedish Master. Graciela Borges (Elena in the film) was extraordinary as usual. And she looks incredibly young and beautiful besides being such a proficient actress. Rita Cortesse (Esther) A winner hands down. What an actress! I will always remember her marvelous film "Herencia" -2001. Valeria Bertuccelli: Perfect casting. Very good actress. Martin Bossi: (Justina in the film) this one could be the Achilles heel in this film. Why? Although his performance is flawless, it was disorienting (to me at least) not to understand his character looks from the very beginning: Nowadays there are so many shades of genres that they blend all together in blurry confusion; could he/she has been a Trans in transition? has he transitioned already? is he just gay? is he a heterosexual man that enjoys dressing up in women's clothes? We'll never know. He plays his character too stiff and almost with fear of being booed by the audience, so one sees all the time a man slightly modified with a miniskirt and a pony tail. The story is very interesting, being a love triangle, they never fail to grab you till the bitter end: Who wins, the wife or the lover? Since even IMDb blows the core of this story without the ubiquitous "spoilers ahead" I assume I won't have any problems talking openly about it. The script is terribly astute and subtle in offering us in small doses the imperceptible changes both women go through in confronting each other under the shadow of the dead husband/lover, traitor in life to both of them. "Widow", singular, "Widows", plural. Clever manipulation for the title, indeed! Meanwhile Esther, Elena's best friend, sees it all (and so does Justina, the Paraguayan maid, working at Elena's home for the last 14 years, and knowing her better that Elena herself. When at the phone, gossiping with a friend, Elena enters and Justina immediately changes from Spanish to Guarani, so Elena won't understand - -by the way, Guaraní is one of the most beautiful and melodious languages on earth-- unfortunately going head on to extinction (caution: I'm NOT Paraguayan). If you are not fully grown up, please, stay away as far as you can from this film as from the Black Plague; it's subject matter, black humor and subtle feelings, all exceed your understanding. I must say that the very end of this film, corny (according to another reviewer) or not, is masterful, it's so sublime that instantly will melt your heart. The beginning of a beautiful, understanding and rock solid friendship. It reminded me of "Les parapluies de Cherbourg". Summing it up: Go and see it.

• Love, Adultery and a Simple Vision About the Question

  zeleao482013-12-26

  'Viudas' is an Argentine movie, so that's to say that it's a movie that came from the most intelligent and sensitive country in South America when one thinks about movie industry. Unfortunately, 'Viudas' is a movie that never defines itself. Is it a black romantic comedy? Is this a drama about love and its pains and losses? Well, whatever the right answer - and that answer must be given by the audience - the outcome is disappointing and unsatisfactory. In fact, 'Viudas' seems like a TV episode in an ordinary soap opera with all the shallowness and weak propositions that is typical in this kind of production. The story concerning the relationship between an old man and a young radio reporter and the discovery of that liaison by the man's wife after his death is treated with almost unrealistic tones and far fetched situations that never involved the audience until the extremely sentimental and routine end. The movie is not so terrible, although its weaknesses. Even here you can find out the sparkle and intensity of movies made in Argentina. The great spotlight here is the hilarious and realistic performance of Rita Cortese.